The Arrowman of the Year award is presented annually to one Youth Arrowman who has rendered the most outstanding service to the Lodge during their tenure in the OA.
Below are the previous recipients.
| Year | Award Recipient |
| 2019 | Chris Johnson |
| 2018 | Nicholas Koenig |
| 2017 | Parker Powell |
| 2016 | Robert Bolton Jr. |
| 2015 | Carter C. Harwell |
| 2014 | Jacob Neville |
| 2013 | Tommy Barfield |
| 2012 | David Fisher |
| 2011 | Chris Clegg |
| 2010 | Matt Morton |
| 2009 | Michael “Dewey” Williams |
| 2008 | Zachary Brailer |
| 2007 | Todd Garcia |
| 2006 | Alex Lee |
| 2005 | Corderra Lee |
| 2004 | Jimmy O’Hara |
| 2003 | Tim DeBow |
| 2002 | Josh Ball |
| 2001 | Joe Dorsey |
| 2000 | Anand Suthar |
| 1999 | Michael Gehrt |
| 1998 | Zachary Smith |
| 1997 | Nicholas Williamson |
| 1996 | Clayton Allport |
| 1995 | Jay Widby |
| 1994 | Mike Junkins |
| 1993 | James Widby |
| 1992 | Clarence Wright |
| 1991 | Gabe Garner |
| 1990 | Jarrell Pair |
| 1989 | Mike Adams |
| 1988 | Graham Murray |
| 1987 | Ken Murray |
| 1986 | Chuck Thomas |
| 1984 | Bill Klukas |
| 1983 | Cameron Nixon |
| 1982 | Paul Raines |
| 1981 | Kenneth Soule |
